Skip to Main Content
SKYCTC Learning Commons

How to Guides: Scholarly vs. Popular

Guides to help with citing sources, using databases, evaluating resources, and exploring types of information.

Scholarly vs. Popular

View this Powerpoint on Scholarly and Popular Articles

Need Help with Research?

Check out these tutorials and guides to assist you with the research process. If you need additional assistance, please contact the help desk at 270-901-1171.

What are Periodicals?

A periodical is any title that is printed or published periodically.  This can be a daily, weekly, monthly, or annual publication.  Because of the frequency of their publication, periodicals are a good source of current information.

Types of Periodicals

Scholarly Journals are written by scholars or professionals who are experts in their fields, are peer reviewed, and are published in a recognized scholarly source, like a journal or by a university publisher.  They are also known as peer-reviewed journals or academic journals.

Popular Magazines are periodicals that contain information and opinions about popular culture and up-to-date information on current events.  They are meant to inform and entertain the general public.

Trade Journals are periodicals published with the intention of marketing ideas, products, or services, to a specific industry or type of trade/business.

Newspapers are serial publications that contain news on current events of special or general interest.  Traditionally newspapers are printed on newsprint paper; but, with the advent of digital publishing, digital newspapers are also being published.

Each of these types of periodicals serves a different purpose.  It is important that you understand those purposes so you know when to use them for assignments.

Which One is a Scholarly Source?

Look at the covers. Are they plain or eye-catching?

picture of Early Childhood Research Quarterly   cover of People magazine

Scholarly Source?
Early Childhood Research Quarterly: 143 votes (95.33%)
People: 7 votes (4.67%)
Total Votes: 150

Is This a Scholarly or Popular Source?

Is there an abstract (summary), charts or graphs, and references?

picture of article   

Scholarly or Popular?
Scholarly: 173 votes (96.65%)
Popular: 6 votes (3.35%)
Total Votes: 179

Which One Is a Popular Source?

Are the articles short or long?

cover of American Journal of Psychotherapy   cover of Time magazine

Popular Source?
American Journal of Psychotherapy: 35 votes (21.47%)
Time: 128 votes (78.53%)
Total Votes: 163